The Curious Case of Those Irresistible Email Subject Lines!

unnikrishna
4 min readJun 11, 2024

The Secrets Behind Those Irresistible Email Subject Lines — And Find Out If You Should Click. Why the Promise of Rewards in Your Inbox Might Be More Than Meets the Eye.

AI prompt generated image by the author

It’s a typical Tuesday, and your inbox is brimming with the usual suspects — newsletters you vaguely remember signing up for receipts from your latest online shopping spree, and a smattering of promotional emails. As you scroll through, one subject line catches your eye: “You are very close to receiving the most rewarding credit card and a gift voucher.

Intriguing, isn’t it? The promise of rewards and the allure of a gift voucher — it’s almost irresistible. But before you hit that apply button, let’s take a moment to unravel the magic behind such a tempting offer.

The Art of the Tease

I’ve been involved and encountered my fair share of these enticing subject lines. The goal is simple: to pique your interest just enough to make you click. It’s all about the tease. But here’s the thing — the best teases don’t just dangle a carrot. They offer something more profound, something uniquely useful or inspirational.

The Seductive Science of Subject Lines

Email marketers are modern-day wordsmiths. They understand that a well-crafted subject line is the gateway to higher open rates. How do they do it? By blending creativity with psychology. Here’s a glimpse behind the curtain:

Personalization: Using your name or tailoring the message to your interests makes it feel more relevant. “Thanu, you’re very close to receiving the most rewarding credit card” feels like it’s speaking directly to you.

Urgency and Scarcity: Words like “very close,” “last chance,” or “limited offer” create a sense of urgency that can prompt quicker action — though a note of caution here. While these phrases can drive engagement, they can also trigger spam filters. Email marketers must balance urgency with spam-avoidance tactics.

Curiosity: Subject lines that leave something to the imagination, like “a gift voucher,” make you want to know more. But do not kill the cat.

Benefit-Oriented: Highlighting a clear benefit, such as rewards or vouchers, directly appeals to what you gain.

The Subtle Seduction

Think about it. Why do we love rewards? It’s not just about the monetary value. It’s about the experience, the possibility of something special, something that feels like a win. And marketers know this. They tap into that little voice inside your head that says, “Hey, you deserve this.”

But here’s the kicker: not all rewards are created equal. Some come with strings attached, hidden fees, or unrealistic spending requirements. So, while the promise of “the most rewarding credit card” sounds delightful, it’s essential to dig deeper.

Cracking the Open Rate Code

Open rates — the percentage of recipients who open an email — are the holy grail for email marketers. A subject line’s allure is pivotal. Here’s what boosts those rates:

A/B Testing: Marketers often test different versions of a subject line to see which performs better.

Conciseness: Keeping it short and punchy ensures the subject line isn’t truncated, especially on mobile devices.

Power Words: Using emotionally charged words like “rewarding,” “exclusive,” or “gift” can significantly impact open rates.

Emojis: Sometimes a well-placed emoji can catch the eye in a sea of text-based subject lines. Not for stiff-upper-lip morons! 🤪

A Better Approach

Now, I’m not here to dissuade you from clicking that button. Instead, let’s arm ourselves with a bit of wisdom. Before diving into any offer, ask yourself these three questions:

What’s the catch? — Is there an annual fee? What are the interest rates? Read the fine print.

Does it align with my spending habits? — A card that offers great travel rewards isn’t much use if you’re a homebody.

Can I trust the source? — Ensure the offer is from a reputable company.

A Little Inspiration

The most rewarding things in life often come with a bit of patience and discernment. Just like crafting the perfect ad, making the right financial decision takes a blend of curiosity, caution, and a dash of boldness.

So, the next time you see an email promising you the moon, take a moment to smile at the cleverness behind it and then consider if it truly serves you. Remember, you hold the power to choose what’s best for you, and that’s the most rewarding thing of all.

A Final Note from the past email broadcaster

And here’s a little confession — if you found yourself captivated by this piece, it’s proof that a well-crafted headline works wonders. Even a past email broadcaster like me can’t resist a good hook. So, hats off to you for following along. Next time, you’ll know just what to look for when that seducing subject line lands in your inbox.

Until next time, stay curious and keep those inbox adventures exciting!

Sign up to discover human stories that deepen your understanding of the world.

Free

Distraction-free reading. No ads.

Organize your knowledge with lists and highlights.

Tell your story. Find your audience.

Membership

Read member-only stories

Support writers you read most

Earn money for your writing

Listen to audio narrations

Read offline with the Medium app

unnikrishna
unnikrishna

Written by unnikrishna

Visual Artist, NFT Creator & Curator, Graphic Designer & Digital Specialist. Comments on: Art Happenings, NFTs, Brands, Visual Art, Digital Art, Art Criticism.

No responses yet

Write a response